Nov 13 2007

What did they eat at the first Thanksgiving feast?

Published by at 9:31 am under History,Holidays,Recipes

New here? Then you may want to subscribe to my RSS feed. Thanks for visiting!

We tend to think that Thanksgiving is all about pumpkin pie, turkey, mashed potatoes, yams and cranberries. In reality, the first Thanksgiving meal in 1621 celebrated by the Plymouth colonists and the Wampanoag Indians didn’t feature any of those items. Historians know for certain that they ate venison and wild fowl. They probably didn’t have much in the way of vegetables that time of year, and they didn’t have ovens in which to make cakes and pies. In fact, there were probably too stuffed on meat to care about eating something sweet. (For more information about the First Thanksgiving, go to History.com and EnjoyMA)

So what could have been on the menu? This comes from Kathleen Curtin, Food Historian at Plimoth Plantation via History.com.

Foods that may have been on the menu

pilgrim-thanksgiving-feastSeafood: cod, eel, clams, lobster (now this is my idea of a great feast!)
Wild Fowl: wild turkey, goose, duck, crane, swan, partridge, eagles
Meat: venison (deer or elk), seal
Grain: wheat flour, Indian corn
Vegetables: pumpkin, peas, beans, onions, lettuce, radishes, carrots
Fruit: plums, grapes

Foods not on the menu

Ham: There is no evidence that the colonists had butchered their pigs though they had brought such animals with them from England.
Sweet Potatoes/Potatoes: These were not common.
Corn on the Cob: Corn was kept dried out at this time of year.
Cranberry Sauce: The colonists had cranberries but no sugar.
Pumpkin Pie: Hard to make without sugar, plus the recipe didn’t exist at this time. However, the pilgrims had recipes for stewed pumpkin.
Chicken/Eggs: We know that the colonists brought hens with them from England, but it’s unknown how many they had left at this point or whether the hens were still laying.
Milk: No cows had been aboard the Mayflower, though it’s possible that the colonists used goat milk to make cheese.

Make your Thanksgiving more authentic

According to EnjoyMA, the Native Americans enjoyed Indian Pudding. This pudding became a favorite of the colonists for centuries to come. However, if you believe History.com (and I tend to think their sources are better) this wouldn’t have been enjoyed at the first Thanksgiving because there was no sugar and they probably didn’t have milk, eggs, lemons, molasses or raisins. But if you have someone in your family who can’t eat gluten, this is a great recipes to traditional bread puddings.

Still, it’s probably something that was enjoyed later during the time of the original 13 colonies. Couldn’t you imagine Ben Franklin having a bowl of this along with a glass of hot mulled wine?

Indian Pudding
Makes 4 to 6 servings.

Ingredients:

  1. j03095692 cups milk
  2. 1 cup stone-ground cornmeal
  3. 2 tablespoons butter, melted
  4. 3/4 cup unsulphured molasses, warmed
  5. 4 tablespoons sugar
  6. 3 eggs, well beaten
  7. 1 teaspoon cinnamon, or to taste
  8. 1/2 teaspoon nutmeg, or to taste
  9. grated peel of 1/2 small lemon
  10. 1/2 cup raisins
  11. sweetened whipped cream or sweet wine for topping

Directions:

  1. Preheat oven to 375 degrees. Heat milk with cornmeal. Whisk from time to time until thick.
  2. Add molasses and butter. Then whisk in sugar.
  3. Gradually beat hot cornmeal mixture into beaten egg. Add cinnamon, nutmeg, lemon peel and raisins.
  4. Place in 8-inch-diameter glass baking dish or ceramic mixing bowl. Bake for 1 hours, or until top is rounded and set.
  5. Serve hot with toppings of whipped cream or sweet wine, if desired.
Print

Like what you see? Subscribe to My Readable Feast for updates!




2 responses so far

2 Responses to “What did they eat at the first Thanksgiving feast?”

  1. Karen (Karooch from Scraps of Mind)on 14 Nov 2007 at 2:10 pm

    Loved the article Anne-Marie. Definitely a Stumble.
    It makes you wonder about our other ‘traditions’ Christmas is a perfect example of how we think we’re doing traditional things but most of the ‘traditions’ are less than 100 years old. Can’t wait to read what you do with that.

  2. Travel Bettyon 20 Nov 2007 at 11:04 am

    Great info, Anne-Marie. I’d be tempted to try a “traditional” Thanksgiving if it weren’t for the lack of sugar!

  • Partner links

  • buy antabuse cash on delivery buy glucophage with mastercard buy priligy paypal without rx i want to order proscar without a prescription propecia finasteride 1mg buy prednisone xr online compazine capsule lioresal fedex shipping proscar overnight online purchase lioresal without rx needed how to get prescription of maxalt maxalt no script fedex prednisone no doctor prescription safety order robaxin buy robaxin no prescription cod buy maxalt online no prescription prednisone without a prescription or order robaxin 100 mg without prescription arimidex delivered overnight finasteride online uk arimidex espana buy cheap finpecia 1mg lisinopril usa buy lisinopril no prescription no prescription arimidex with fedex us maxalt fedex buy arimidex without a perscription overnight premarin without a rx purchase premarin without a prescription online buying metformin where to purchase premarin no prescription no fees where can i purchase premarin online orlistat order online pharmacy premarin where can i get cytotec without a prescription arimidex without rx overnight shipping finpecia canada requip buy premarin pay cod buy finasteride online without dr approval seroquel oral proscar u.p.s shipping cod how to order priligy online without a rx buy maxalt online prescription buy cytotec australia no prescription no prescription robaxin next day order maxalt pay pal online without rx buy robaxin in uk buy generic lioresal buy proscar without prescription where buy glucophage lioresal online cash on delivery buy glucophage doctor prescription how to get maxalt prescription how to get prescription of lioresal celebrex uk online glucophage purchase discount maxalt overnight buy metformin from india buy orlistat without a prescription premarin shipped by cash on delivery purchase premarin online without rx fedex finasteride overnight without a prescription buy maxalt online with overnight delivery maxalt overnight no script mastercard accepted how to get prednisone online no prescription in 20 days buy cheap lisinopril without prescription cheap metformin uk arimidex without rx medications cheap requip uk buy 1 mg arimidex cheap generic premarin where to buy cytotec no prescription d3wwqa maxalt online no perscription fedex cytotec online purchase prednisone tablets 40 mg no prescription australia arimidex online no prescription premarin shipped by cash on delivery purchase cheap arimidex cod free fedex seroquel oral uk buy requip purchase premarin no scams finpecia cost buy prednisone online without prescription from canada purchase cheap prescription maxalt maxalt on line no perscription arimidex buy lisinopril on line amex arimidex cheap no rx required canada metformin purchased online without prescription purchase finasteride cod next day delivery no prescription maxalt with fedex premarin citrate order cytotec online finasteride fedex without a prescription buy rx premarin without premarin u.p.s shipping cod metformin generic cytotec 100mg tablets express shipping arimidex online purchase order generic seroquel finasteride online buy maxalt online without a script cytotec 100 mg without a prescription prednisone online sale without prescription seroquel mexico want to buy premarin in malaysia online overnight shipping maxalt cheap prices on cytotec canada cytotec buy lisinopril online from canada buy metformin on line without a rx arimidex precio orlistat prescription online next day delivery generic metformin prices purchase maxalt amex online without rx buy cytotec online canada buying maxalt without a prescription medikament requip purchase online arimidex without prescription buy arimidex free consultation cytotec no prescription needed 200mg medikament arimidex rizatriptan 10 mg cheap maxalt by money order purchase arimidex cod delivery requip uk prescription seroquel buy finpecia 1mg no prescription where to purchase cheap arimidex no rx maxalt without persription order maxalt 10 mg without prescription order finasteride no prescription prednisone prescription cost pharmacy lisinopril no prescription generic prednisone finasteride without presciption fluconazole precio buy antabuse online with a debit card purchasing lioresal without a script where to buy maxalt no prescription no fees purchase online priligy without rx buy cheap online pharmacy priligy buy maxalt without a prescription overnight shipping maxalt online with no prescription or membership online overnight shipping lioresal buy fluconazole without a prescription lioresal with no presciption where can i buy some cytotec online only using cash or money orders where to buy glucophage online how to buy lioresal online without a rx order premarin free next day airpremarin on line how to get a finasteride prescription seroquel overnight buy online maxalt without rx buy metformin 850mg buy lisinopril amex cheapest place to buy seroquel ordering arimidex over the counter order finasteride without prescription purchase finasteride no visa online without prescription canadian pharmacy prednisone buy discount requip on line finasteride without a dr lisinopril oral buy premarin on line amex order arimidex no visa without rx premarin canada maxalt with no prescriptions buy cheap fedex premarin order orlistat no prescription purchase finasteride cod delivery order finasteride without a rx overnight shipping purchase premarin without finasteride no script how to order cytotec online without a prescription buy seroquel epharmacist maxalt online doctors where can i buy requip online without a prescription finpecia 1 mg order online finpecia 1mg side effects where can i get cytotec without a prescription buying finasteride online without a prescription buy requip pills in toronto maxalt no dr cytotec cheap on online 850 mg metformin buy no online rx metformin lisinopril without rx metformin espana requip side effects buy pharmacy seroquel waterview lisinopril buy metformin apotheke buying finasteride over the counter buy lisinopril in united states online requip buy buy arimidex without prescription requip wholesale c.o.d finasteride arimidex capsule prednisone without rx finasteride ups fedex shipping. prescription premarin purchase arimidex amex online without prescription no prescription premarin with fedex arimidex usa purchase premarin without prescription to ship overnight pharmacy where you can purchase arimidex cash on delivery no prescriptions needed for maxalt metformin cheap no rx required canada finasteride without a prescription shipped overnight express buy cheap metformin prezzo metformin finpecia online australia purchase maxalt without prescription purchase cheap online maxalt safety order premarin buy lisinopril with a mastercard uk requip generic buy lisinopril discount generic lisinopril prices requip and valacyclovir purchase finasteride without a prescription online buy lisinopril visa order arimidex without rx needed lisinopril usa canada prednisone buy maxalt online without rx maxalt without persription order no online rx arimidex buy propecia (finpecia) online prednisone cheap on online metformin rezept lisinopril best buy buy premarin 0,625mg without rx from us pharmacy prednisone 40 mg available at health department achat lisinopril 10 mg how to order maxalt 5 mg online without a prescription buy finasteride 5mg buy rx premarin 0,625mg without seroquel 200mg order finpecia 1 mg dose hair finasteride depression side effects order generic requip 2mg online requip 2mg tabletten metformin 1000mg cheap mexican buy 1mg finasteride purchase premarin 0,625mg without a prescription overnight shipping premarin 0,625mg buy cod cytotec 100 mcg 100mg tablets express shipping best place to buy cytotec 100 mcg online? order seroquel 200mg online requip 2mg toronto premarin 0,625mg tabletten maxalt 5 mg buy fedex order orlistat 120 mg online no prescription pharma life online requip 2mg purchase premarin 0,625mg without rx overnight shipping finpecia 1 mg where can i buy prednisone 40 mg seroquel 200mg 300mg maxalt 5 mg online no perscription maxalt 5 mg online cash on delivery premarin 0,625mg sale buy feldene discount online us feldene lamictal effects keflex online no rx overnight ordering casodex online without a precription keflex no script fedex lamictal visa buy arcoxia australia no prescription i want to buy pregnizone without a prescription asacol bestellen buy cod atarax low price rx online website tenormin buy desogen cheap online buy desogen without a percsription order arimidex pharmacy finasteride doctor requip tablets no prescription prednisone finasteride overnight without rx order finasteride online next day delivery order arimidex no rx buy prednisone online made in america purchase online prescription maxalt buy premarin once a day metformin cash on delivery buy requip visa order arimidex on line order premarin for cash on delivery buy brand metformin metformin and metformin buy cheap maxalt without a perscription maxalt without a perscription or membership buy generic seroquel finasteride doctor consult finasteride without persription buy 0.625 mg premarin how to purchase arimidex online without rx buying lisinopril prednisone purchase without prescription prednisone discount lioresal overnight buying priligy online without a prescription fincar express online order compazine buy celebrex fed ex purchase lioresal amex online without prescription online pharmacy fluconazole buy prednisone from a usa pharmacy without a prescription buy in baclofen uk priligy no script fedex lioresal fast delivery no doctors buy fluconazole cod order cytotec mastercard where to buy priligy no prescription no fees robaxin no doctor prescription purchase proscar without prescription pay cod diflucan without prescription overnight lioresal without a prescription buying baclofen buy diflucan no prescription purchase cheap diflucan online purchase cheap robaxin cod free fedex order diflucan without a prescription cheap maxalt without a prescription order priligy cheap no membership fees no prescription glucophage to buy buy lioresal next day delivery purchase lioresal money purchase diflucan rezept purchase robaxin pay pal online without rx buy prednisone no scams order robaxin amex online without prescription proscar non prescription us proscar fedex buying diflucan online compazine uk sales buy lioresal no prescription needed cytotec available at health department buying compazine online safecompazine suppliers maxalt shipped c.o.d. purchase lioresal online without script cheap order rx arcoxia buy principen without a prescription overnight delivery desogen buy on line where can i purchase cleocin online india asacol lamictal uk i want to buy cleocin without a prescription vantin free consultation fedex overnight delivery cheapest cleocin online i need to order cycrin without a prescription order generic atarax how to buy vantin without a prescription buy lamictal without a rx overnight delivery arcoxia with overnight fedex casodex online consultation buy lamictal with amex order keflex online consultation order atarax for cash on delivery buy real keflex free fedex delivery feldene benicar overnight no script mastercard accepted buy asacol without prescription desogen fedex without a prescription cycrin without a rx feldene non rx fedex overnight free principen online no rx overnight online pharmacy asacol order atarax online with overnight delivery buy zovirax in mo zovirax buy cod tenormin without prescriptions in usa buy asacol without a prescription keflex sale no prescription tenormin uk buy desogen buy prescription cleocin online buy generic atarax from india buy revia online without prescription from canada buy cycrin without a prescription purchase zovirax pay pal online without rx purchase principen online no membership best asacol online pill buy revia on line without a rx buy prescription keflex online zovirax without prescription or membership where can i buy some casodex online only using cash or money orders tenormin xr online generic zovirax usa desogen shipped cod order cycrin online where can i purchase vantin no rx buy cheap lamictal no prescription buy asacol next day delivery generic benicar without a precsriptions ordering tenormin online without a prescription feldene without prescription or membership buy cheap cleocin line where to buy cheap lamictal no prescription buy revia over the counter cheapest place to buy atarax nonprescription keflex where to purchase cycrin no prescription no fees asacol no prescription to buy desogen prescription from s online revia purchase without prescription lamictal online consultant ordering revia online buy lamictal no prescription principen without a dr buy cheap cycrin online online cleocin arcoxia generic sale order vantin free next day airvantin on line generic zovirax without prescription canada purchase cleocin visa buy keflex and keflex buy asacol without a r x buy principen without a prescription overnight delivery purchasing cleocin online without prescription order orlistat overnight orlistat online sale without prescription purchase arimidex without a rx online buy premarin amex online without rx buy finpecia propecia purchase arimidex pay pal without rx cheap purchase finasteride buy cheap online pharmacy finasteride cheap premarin uk buy metformin cash on delivery buy arimidex money buy purchase finasteride cod cash delivery where to purchase generic finasteride online without a rx i need to order prednisone without presciption and order it cod pay cod for prednisone without prescription finasteride online buy saturday delivery buy metformin in united states online buy generic orlistat online no prescription quick delivery buy cheap requip online free consult buy discount metformin arimidex cheap no rx required canada buy finasteride online overnight buy cheapest requip and requip finasteride online best buy premarin buy lisinopril in the uk metformin overdose orlistat online no prescriptions required from the us buy prednisone online without a prescription buy finasteride without a maxalt finasteride in mexico without a prescription prednisone buy premarin toronto metformin drug buy arimidex online cheap maxalt no script buy no online rx metformin arimidex without doctor prescription requip online purchase buy genuine lisinopril online buy seroquel canada lisinopril apotheke order metformin overnight lisinopril without rx finpecia depression women buy lisinopril with a mastercard buy seroquel visa purchase premarin amex online without prescription buy requip cheap online buy finasteride proscar/propecia mail order finasteride seroquel sale prednisone buy no prescription buy requip online with a debit card premarin canada order premarin online next day delivery buy cheap lisinopril on line buy no prior prescription lisinopril buy lisinopril shipped cod finasteride online uk prednisone no prescription needed buying lisinopril online arcoxia bestellen arcoxia cheap uk atarax generic order zovirax online feldene buy cheap buy lamictal without a credit card buy feldene fed ex buy in tenormin uk cheap keflex buying casodex with no rx principen mastercard order order cycrin online no membership overnight shipping buy discounted vantin online cheap zovirax no script casodex online doctors free keflex purchase online rx premarin without buy finpecia online where can i buy cytotec over the counter buy finasteride no r x cheap metformin online prescription maxalt overnight fedex premarin online uk buy maxalt on line without a perscription requip purchased online without prescription maxalt without prescription mexico want to buy premarin in usa where can i order cytotec online prednisone generic sale maxalt doctor consult buy maxalt cost buy finasteride in uk purchase requip pay pal without rx buy prednisone oral buy orlistat online 120 mg no prescription maxalt no rx order finasteride without a prescription overnight shipping order lisinopril usa buy lisinopril in united states online metformin uk buy metformin diet pills buy online requip non prescription prednisone buy seroquel online with a debit card want to buy lisinopril in malaysia buy valacyclovir and requip seroquel canada canada lisinopril purchase generic finpecia 1 mg buy requip 2mg american express order maxalt 5 mg no visa orlistat 120 mg precio finasteride generic vs propecia cheapest way to buy finasteride metformin 1000mg online order buy finasteride online paypal online pharmacy orlistat 120 mg no prescription prednisone 40 mg cheap on online buy finasteride 5mg online buy maxalt 5 mg without a prescription online buy cheap premarin 0,625mg without prescription buy low cost seroquel 200mg buy requip 2mg 2 mg orlistat 120 mg generic online maxalt 5 mg generic cheapest order finasteride uk order lisinopril 10 mg overnight buy discount lisinopril 10 mg online canada cytotec 100 mcg premarin 0,625mg without rx overnight shipping buy cheap requip 2mg online free consult buy maxalt 5 mg without prescription to ship overnight metformin 1000mg toronto premarin 0,625mg with free fedex overnight orlistat 120 mg with no rx finasteride finasteride depression priligy mastercard where to buy cheap proscar no prescription priligy on line no script maxalt no prior script how to purchase lioresal online without a prescription buy prednisone without prescription purchase cheap celebrex online cheapest glucophage prednisone no doctor prescription order prednisone without a prescription buy cheap compazine without prescription antabuse for pets baclofen no prescription fluconazole mexico buy discount celebrex compazine buy compazine no prescription prednisone next day buy compazine no prescription low cost cytotec online purchase pharmacy glucophage purchase cheap online priligy order lioresal no visa without rx canadian pharmacy maxalt where to buy baclofen priligy no prescription overnight glucophage side effects buy cheap diflucan online free consult fincar over the counter lioresal without prescription or membership proscar no script required express delivery maxalt overnight without rx prednisone overnight without rx where can i buy compazine without prescription no prescription proscar cod delivery how to order maxalt online without a prescription purchase proscar no visa without prescription generic cytotec without prescription canada buy lioresal no prescription buy compazine free consultation where can i purchase prednisone online diflucan prescription order lioresal overnight cheap us prednisone fedex finasteride dose hair buy prednisone 20 mg legal buy finasteride online buy premarin 0,625mg without a rx buy cheap lisinopril 10 mg line buy discount lisinopril 10 mg on line buying premarin 0,625mg online without rx premarin 0,625mg usa buy cheap requip 2mg buy requip 2mg without a perscription purchase online maxalt 5 mg without rx buy rx premarin 0,625mg without buy cytotec 100 mcg online canada orlistat 120 mg overnight without prescription seroquel 200mg and quetiapine metformin 1000mg no prescription overnight maxalt 5 mg free consultation u.s. pharmacy maxalt 5 mg cheap online buy 1 mg requip 2mg generic seroquel 200mg prices wholesale lisinopril 10 mg cheap purchase premarin 0,625mg without a prescription overnight shipping buy premarin 0,625mg without rx from us pharmacy buy premarin 0,625mg in the uk buy lisinopril 10 mg without prescription cheap orlistat 120 mg no prescription order no online rx metformin 1000mg generic orlistat 120 mg online no prescription buy lisinopril 10 mg legally buy premarin 0,625mg online us pharmacy cheap prednisone 40 mg online no prescription cheapest finasteride available online generic finasteride online canadian synthroid diet pills without a prescription where can i purchase synthroid online purchase online prescription arimidex seroquel espana cheap lisinopril usa buy orlistat oral orlistat 120 mg for sale usa buy rx arimidex without uk buy arimidex buy discount arimidex on line order generic orlistat online no prescription finasteride ordering without dr fedex finasteride overnight without a rx online pharmacy premarin quetiapine 300 mg where can i purchase arimidex no rx buy seroquel no rx is it legal to buy orlistat online buy lisinopril money buy synthroid c.o.d. buy discount premarin on line premarin no prescription overnight orlistat order overnight prednisone with no rx canada requip is it legal to buy orlistat online buy premarin online now buy generic finpecia uk purchase premarin without rx to ship overnight premarin without prescription shipped overnight express buy prescription finasteride online arimidex uk no prescription premarin metformin apotheke buy premarin offshore no prescription fedex purchase online prescription maxalt without premarin overnight no consult maxalt on line no script prezzo premarin lisinopril online prescription overnight no prescription prednisone finasteride 1mg canada buy maxalt online no membership order cheap overnight finasteride cheap synthroid without a prescription purchase arimidex on line no rx prednisone in usa order buy requip online lisinopril suppliers free premarin purchase arimidex on line no rx uk order seroquel buy premarin on line without a rx premarin buy fedex finpecia generic vs propecia purchase arimidex without a rx online premarin without prescription orlistat no script metformin wholesale buy metformin with mastercard online purchase maxalt finpecia costco pharmacy orlistat over the counter maxalt perscription from s online buy cytotec online canada how to buy cytotec without a prescription no prescripton finasteride how to purchase prednisone buy genuine prednisone in the u.s.
    Copy Protected by Tech Tips's CopyProtect Wordpress Blogs.